[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] says waterproof but apparently not in slush. Was working with my “waterproof” boots on and within an hour my shoes had puddles in them.

If I Could Choose Only One Winter Boot, This Is It

Awesome boots! Bought in black 5ish years ago and contemplating another pair. Plenty warm for Vermont, very comfortable and not stiff (virtually no break-in period). Purchased size 7.5 (1/2 size up from my usual size 7 in sneakers) so I'd have room for thick socks. Thanks to the folks at Columbia! Please keep making these!

Will Buy Again If Needed

I bought these a couple months ago not so much for snow but i work nights outside and it rains alot so mainly needed my feet to stay dry and warm. Its rained several times but last night was the true test for these bad boys. It was dumping buckets of rain and hail all night, huge puddles, and very cold. I was wearing sweats under my pants, and was absolutely soaked through and through, except for my feet. My feet stayed completely dry and warm all night!! I highly recommend these for cold weather and rainy nights

Ice Maiden Ii Women's Boots

I bought these last Feb 2024. I took them out if my closet this winter 2025 and wore them a few times. I was surprised that these boots didn't have a loop on the back to pull them on. Without that, it makes them a bit harder to slip them on. I wish I would have noticed that a year ago! I also want to mention that these boots are not as warm as the reviews stated. It was 12 degrees here in last night Feb 20th 2025 and my feet were cold while walking. Like they say, You win some & you lose some. On a high note the sizing is spot on.

Bestest Boots Ever!

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I absolutely love the Ice Maiden boots. I have a pair in black that are about 8 years old and still going. The tread has worn down a lot, so I decided it was time to get a new pair. This time I bought grey for a bit of a change. They are just as comfy as my first pair and have helped me navigate the snow and ice very easily. Don't ever stop meshing these!